Last night I thread-traced all the markings for the buttonholes (truthfully, there’s no other way to mark the mohair!).  This morning I got up early and put in all five buttonholes, with very little effort (except on the first one where I accidentally sewed the buttonhole on the wrong side of the fabric!).

I don’t know why bound buttonholes are supposed to be difficult.  It’s admittedly a little more complicated  than simply zigzagging around the edges and cutting a slit open for a machine buttonhole, but as long as you remember the steps it’s not hard.  I’m amused by a Threads article in my “Jackets, Coats, and Suits” book that recommends having a professional tailor put in your bound buttonholes.  It’s not that hard!

(Sometimes I think 90% of being able to do the unusual is simply not realizing (or refusing to believe) that it’s difficult.  I remember that as a 13-year-old I started up an underground newsletter for a summer program I had been to…I had 68 subscribers to the magazine, which was printed on pink ditto-masters and titled “The Scarlet Newsletter” or some such.  I had friends writing articles for it, even a little fundraising drive – and I managed to do all that because my parents never told me this was difficult.  They helped me find pink ditto-masters and figure out one or two problems along the way, but other than that they acted like it was a perfectly normal thing for a 13-year-old to do.  And because they didn’t say anything, I never realized how unusual it was to be doing that!  My parents had their foibles, but they were dead right on how to encourage me  in my little adventures.)

The buttonholes aren’t perfect – there’s a tiny bit of gapping in the middle, maybe 1/16 of an inch in some places, but they look pretty good.  More to the point, from the first one to the fifth one there’s a noticeable improvement in quality, which makes me pretty happy.  I could conceivably have gotten better results by basting the lips together before sewing down the triangles on the end, but since I’m working with suede, basting would have been quite difficult, and would have left marks.  Suede is more forgiving than smooth leather, but not by much.

I think my next set of buttonholes will be better, so it’s good that I’m doing the practice coat.

Despite 11 hour days at work, I have been working on bound buttonholes, practicing and trying several different methods.  Here are two of them, along with a button:

I gave up on the second one halfway through as I didn’t like the look of it at all.  The organza patch was supposed to press invisibly away, but obviously didn’t.  I also couldn’t see how to get piped buttonhole lips into the window gracefully (and didn’t think that flat lips would look good with the fluffy coat fabric).  Finally, pressing from the front as instructed crushed the fluffy “pile” of the mohair.  The first method worked perfectly and is the method I will use in the coat.

I think the second method would work  better with a fabric that is not as lofty and not as hard to press.  (I’m still trying to figure out how to press the seams without squishing  the  fabric, but perhaps I can either (1) brush it afterwards to bring up the nap again, or (2) look up how one presses velvet.  This is obviously a  problem that other people have dealt with, so I just have to find out how.)

At any rate, I like my bound buttonholes, so my next step will be putting them into the coat.  That will be fun!  I really enjoyed making the first bound buttonhole and am looking eagerly forward to doing more.  Funny since I hate doing machine-worked buttonholes.  I don’t know why bound buttonholes are so much fun to me, but they are.

Things have been moving a bit slower than I would have liked, but I am making some progress.  On Daryl’s advice, and after testing several options, I bought a yard and a half of tightly woven plum-colored flannel to use for interfacing.  I drafted the interfacing patterns, cut out the interfacing, and marked it with roll lines, buttonholes, darts, and center front.  I am just about ready to start tailor-basting the interfacing to the coat, and padstitching the lapels.

This is where things get a bit confusing.  Claire Shaeffer’s book, while it covers the main points, doesn’t provide a complete blow-by-blow description of the process.  For example, she doesn’t specify when to add the buttonholes or when to add welt pockets (though she does give instructions elsewhere in the book for creating both).  She does say that couturiers add the buttonholes near the end, not during the initial construction.  But since my last experience in making buttonholes was at least ten years ago (and I have never made a bound buttonhole), I’m not sure I want to wrestle with buttonholes in a nearly-finished jacket.  Doing them earlier just seems smarter considering my experience level.  So I think that, for this first coat anyway, I will do the buttonholes first.

Of course, doing the buttonholes early means that you have the buttons ready.  Since I had planned to make the coat with suede buttons (using the same suede as for the collar/lapel), this meant making the buttons myself.  So I spent some time this evening experimenting with make-your-own-button kits, and discovered that they just aren’t designed for material as heavy as suede.

So instead I took a slightly rounded button with a long shank and covered it with suede, the old-fashioned way.  I cut a circle from the suede, about twice the diameter of the button.  Then I sewed a gathering stitch around the edges, put the button in the center, and pulled both ends of the thread until I had a nice tight gather right around the shank, and the button was smoothly covered in suede.  Looks really nice (except on the back side, which nobody is going to see) and the results are quite durable, I’d expect.  I used heavy-duty thread to reduce stretch and to make sure it held.

That part was easy.

Now I am reading through books to make sure I understand the assembly process.  It is a slow process, because I have three good books on sewing jackets and they sometimes contradict each other.  So I am reading all three, trying to understand the motivations of the author in making that recommendation.  Sometimes it’s speed, sometimes it’s simplifying for the  inexperienced, sometimes it just seems arbitrary.  It’s a little overwhelming, but I’m letting myself puzzle it out because the important part is not actually getting the coat done; it’s learning how to think about fabric, how it behaves and how to work with it.  And the way you learn how to do that is not by blindly following instructions, but by reading and thinking closely about what you are doing and why.  This takes longer, but I’ve got patience.

So I am back to my high-school and college days: reading texts, taking notes, and writing in my notebook my understanding of what they are recommending and why, and also my plans for moving forward.  Because it’s easy to get bored, confused, or just plain overwhelmed with this much information, I plan to do this in tandem with a couple of fairly straightforward things: padstitching the lapels and collar, making the buttons, and practicing bound buttonholes.  All  of these are relatively simple and relatively time-consuming, giving me plenty of time to think while still making progress.

So stay tuned…in a day, a week, a month I’ll start to understand this…and then, by all the myriad gods, THERE WILL BE FIREWORKS!!